Sharks roster looks better or worse?

The San Jose Sharks roster looks vaguely familiar at this point in the off-season. Perhaps that’s because it’s virtually the same team that took them to the Western Conference Finals last season.

That finish warranted few alterations to the roster, but are the Sharks in any better shape to improve on last season’s breakthrough in the playoffs?

Despite a few changes, it’s hard to argue that the Sharks roster looks about the same, if not a little worse.

When they were eliminated, it was clear that some players wouldn’t be back the next season.

Change in Net

One of Evgeni Nabokov or Patrick Marleau was due to be left behind because of salary cap contraints. The team decided that player should be Nabokov.

They then proceeded to replace Nabokov with a much cheaper alternative in Antero Niittymaki. Niittymaki will join forces with Thomas Greiss to protect the Sharks net.

The judgement on this change won’t be determined until halfway through the season, or maybe not until the playoffs. Niittymaki is a proven goaltender but has never had a team of this caliber in front of him. It’s anyone’s guess how he’ll fair in the playoffs or if the Sharks will take a chance with Greiss instead.

Verdict: Undetermined

Defense/Captain

Rob Blake announced his retirement in early summer and the Sharks have yet to find a suitable replacement.

They will return seven other defenseman who saw action last season in Dan Boyle, Marc-Edouard Vlasic, Douglas Murray, Kent Huskins, Nicklas Wallin, Jason Demers, and Jay Leach.

If no more moves are made on the back end, then it simply means that these players will see increased responsibilities from last year. One of which may include wearing the captain’s “C” in Boyle’s case.

The consensus is that Demers will have a greatly expanded role in taking over Blake’s power-play time. As to who will be playing alongside Vlasic this season, it could be any of the latter four players mentioned above.

The team has also yet to choose Blake’s successor as captain. Boyle appears to be the favorite, but Marleau, Joe Thornton and Joe Pavelski all have to be considered in the discussion.

It is well-documented that this unit is not as strong as it was last year.

The next step for the Sharks would be a Stanley Cup appearance. Looking at the teams who’ve accomplished that the last few years, they all have above-average defense-corps. As of right now, the Sharks do not.

Verdict: Downgrade

Bottom-6 Forwards

If there’s one fairly different look outside of the net, it’s in the Shark’s bottom six forwards.

Manny Malhotra was due for a big raise after the successful season he had at a huge bargain last season. His impact will hopefully be replaced by Logan Couture who made great strides in his rookie season between the AHL with Worcester and in San Jose.

Other familiar faces in the Sharks lineup from last season include Scott Nichol, Torrey Mitchell and Jamie McGinn. Malhotra, Jed Ortmeyer, Jody Shelley, and Brad Staubitz will not be back in teal.

That leaves two available lineup spots that will probably be duked out in training camp by prospects and camp invitees. Last season the Sharks got contributions from Benn Ferriero, Ryan Vesce, and Frazer McLaren. They should be front-runners for those spots.

Some of the Sharks’ success in the first two rounds last season was because their bottom-6 forwards made contributions in a number of ways. There’s nothing that really inspires any kind of new enthusiasm from this group right now. Again, it appears that players with limited experience will be asked to do much more as regulars this year (Couture, McGinn). The team appears to be banking on improvements within their own individual players.

Verdict: Downgrade

Top-6 Forwards

With Devin Setoguchi’s newly signed 1-year deal worth $1.8 million, the Sharks will return the same top two lines that drove their success through the regular season and into the playoffs last season.

Thornton, Marleau, Dany Heatley, Pavelski, and Ryane Clowe will join Setoguchi once again.

There have been some questions as to how these players will be arranged. Marleau, Thornton, and Heatley formed one of the best lines in hockey last season. Pavelski, Clowe and Setoguchi carried the Sharks through their first round series of the playoffs and were the team’s best line down the stretch during the regular season.

This is the same unit that was responsible for most of the team’s success last year. They’ll be expected to do even more this year if the team has any hope of reaching it’s first Stanley Cup birth in the franchises history.

Verdict: Equal

Based on those broad subgroups, it appears the Sharks are actually a little worse on paper than they were last season. Obviously, names don’t guarantee anything. Neither does “expected” outcome. Ultimately it will be up to this group to make GM Doug Wilson’s moves pay off when the season rolls around.

Share this nice post:

Filed Under: San Jose Sharks

Tags:

About the Author: I am a journalism senior @ San Diego State University. Live, die and breath all sports; hardcore Bay Area fan. Playing guitar and sports is my downtime, usually in some combination with movies (making and watching).

RSSComments (8)

Leave a Reply | Trackback URL

  1. PenguinsMarch says:

    Tejus: Great update. I tend to rely on you now for SJS news. I had thought Wilson’s offer sheet to Hjalmarsson was bluffing, but after reading this, clearly not. He would have been a great add to the D.

    Also, I wonder if Nittymaki will sink or swim if he wins the starting job. He was always someone’s backup in Philly (Biron) or TB last year. Wonder if he’ll put too much pressure on himself to not blow this chance to be on a legitimate contender finally.

    • Tejus Govindjie says:

      Thanks Adrian. There’s rumors they’re still looking to add to the D and they have the cap space (~$3 million).

      I agree about Niittymaki, he’s absolutely the wildcard for this season. Sharks hope he thrives in the starting role the same way he did in the Olympics a few years back.

  2. Chris On Fire says:

    Dude, Shelley was traded last deadline for water bottles.

  3. Richard says:

    The sentence you’re complaining about says that Shelley will not be back with the Sharks.

    Malhotra, Jed Ortmeyer, Jody Shelley, and Brad Staubitz will not be back in teal.

  4. seashark says:

    how come no one talks about griess. he’s going to be playing around 30-40 games, with the possibility of taking over the number 1 spot. in the limited games last year he played well. also couture will get a lot more minutes this year and will be an offensive upgrade from malholtra.

    • Tejus Govindjie says:

      I think if the Sharks really believe in Greiss this should be his chance. They have quite a few goal-tending prospects who could be part of the team soon so they need to find out what Greiss can do with consistent playing time now.

      You’re right about Couture bringing more offensively. He won’t replace Malhotra’s face-off proficiency or his penalty killing though.

  5. robot says:

    Unhappy for the vast practice, but I’m real the new Zune, and hope this, as asymptomatic as the fantabulous reviews few otherwise grouping tally scrivened, leave meliorate you decide if it’s the starboard for you.

  6. I have been meaning to post something like this on one of my blogs and this gave me an idea. Thanks.