Some Positives For The NY Islanders Thus Far
BDGallof | Dec 26, 2009 | Comments 6
BD Reports from Sunny Florida
It is another cool winters eve if Florida. A cigar is lit as I wax philosophic. Both fans twirl with a faint creak, as I watch the smoke swirl upwards.
Let’s talk some hockey…
Look, I know as well as you do hockey took a big backseat for what has been a wreck to all our nervous systems with the Lighthouse Project. We’ll go into that in a few days. In the meantime, Nick Giglia, as usual, has done a bang on job of reporting on it.
Let’s look at some of the good this year like:
John Tavares:
Oh he can’t skate? He’s a complete liability on the ice? Overrated?
As his former coach told us, as we discussed this past summer as I told you all not to worry about those Hedman and Duchene rumors…Tavs was, is and will be the real deal.
Poise. Positioning. Liquid-like hands. He has made himself a large part of the Isles offense leading the team in points.
Nobody can walk away from a game thinking any negatives. He has been better than advertised by that silly backseat analysis that was nitpicking over this past summer and early last year.
And what makes it truly warming…he’s going to get better.

Matt Moulson:
Isles fans who missed Jason Blake have found the new LA King castoff who has made himself an integral part of the Isles offense. He uses his size and makes teams pay when focusing on Okposo and Tavares.
Reminds me of Parrish, yet speedier and without that streakiness and confidence issues. Moulson is hungry and shows it everytimes he is on the ice.
He is what you call a fan favorite and the kind of story that just goes to show opportunity can bring out the best sometimes.
Dwayne Roloson:
Leadership matters. He doesn’t just get better play in front of him by accident. He took a bit to get going, looking a bit rusty in game 1, but has since shown that he was a brilliant signing for this young team.
Look no further to his goaltending to why they competed and held for ties early in the season.
Yes, he’s not young, but in a lot of ways he is the best goaltender they have had since DP’s all-star level season. Better than Osgood, Snow, Dunham or anyone else in the last decade or more.
Let’s drink to his health and longevity.
Jack Hillen:
On a team of lackluster defense, Hillen is showing some real growth in year 2. He’s plugged himself into the top half of the Isles defense and when Isles fans gasped as he went down to a puck recently, you realized how much he matters to a talent deficient defense.
Hillens growth might have placed himself permently in front of Bruno Gervais, Freddy Meyer, and even Brendan Witt on the depth chart. He has what the Isles have looked for in defense, despite not exactly big on size: speed, skill, potential and upside. These are things that might portend major changes after this season for those who I just listed as Hillen looks to be part of the Isles future.
Scott Gordon:
Year 2 of his 3 year deal is about growth and the results speak for themselves thus far. To be from last place to into the mix with only one good line on offense and a severely flawed defense is a testament.
Trent Hunter:
If he played all the games instead of going down to injury, he might be giving Tavares and Moulson some serious competition for points leader.
He plays a well-rounded game and I consider him part of their top two line futures. As does the Isles. He does whatever is asked of him.
He might not be the fastest, but he’s dangerous, banging, and scrappy. His positioning this year has been better and has really been a big help to the team since coming back for adding some scoring prowess beyond the top line while not exactly with counterparts that are top tier.
Andy Sutton:
Many seem to not realize his positive effect on the Isles and his ability to play the Gordon gameplan. Last year, before his longterm injury, he was one of the few with an excellent +/- rating indicating as such. Some were unconvinced.
Well, this year, be no longer. He has dished out hits like lunatic, yet stayed out of the penalty box. He has a meanstreak a mile long. And he’s been exactly what the Isles have needed in the 3-4 depth chart physical pivot.
Had the Yukon hit Sutton, the driver would have dragged out of the truck and beaten.
This team needs Sutton. If there are any deficiencies, it’s only because he’s been asked to do so much due to the severe lack on D due to talent and injuries.
Filed Under: Featured • New York Islanders
About the Author: B.D. Gallof is a published writer and hockey blogger. He is also one of the charter members of the NY Islander's Blog Box program. He was the NY Islanders blogger for Hockeybuzz.com from 2007 till the beginning of 2009, building their Isles presence to almost whopping half a million visits.
BD has been written up in Sports Illustrated, TSN.ca, the NY Times Slapshots blog, Yahoo's Puck Daddy blog and SportsBusiness Journal.
A big question for the Islanders rebuilding plan is do they sign Sutton to a contract for next season and beyond or try to trade him at the deadline for a draft pick and or prospect or both. In my opinion our defense lacks so much talent, size and depth we should try to sign him because of his overall play and his physical pressence which we sorely need. I’d like to here your opinion on this BD. Thanks
I’d resign him. He does well in gordo’s system, has physical presence and hits. He fights, and does what is needed.
To me, the wrong man’s contract was extended a while back. Brendan Witt has become expendable, Sutton is a needed factor for the defense.
Its a shame that KO didn’t make it as positive..His lack of goal production hasnt stopped him from working hard every shift…Hope he starts finding the back of the net…
The Isles are so much better with Sutton in the lineup…I think it would be a mistake not to keep him
Despite having only half an nhl defense and 1/3 of an nhl offense, the Isles have stayed within sight of the 8th spot DESPITE coach Gordon. While the team has bought into his system, Gordon rewarded players with playing time not deserved. The biggest examples are Gervais, Park and Thompson. It took until mid December for Gervais to be a healthy scratch despite being the worst Islander defender in the Wang era. Then he sits for only 2 games to sit FM4 who’s play has been sketchy as well. MacDonald’s play on the Minnesota trip should have shown Gordo that Gervais could have sat games at that moment. Then there is Gordo’s decision to play the 4th line in all situations no matter the situation. Down 2 goals in the third…give them a reg. shift. 4 on 4 v. Stamkos & St.Louis, let’s put Park and Thompson out there. The Islanders have no true 4th line, but we play guys like Sim, Thompson and Park despite the fact that we should be giving kids like Comeau, Tambellini and SChremp a good look. They have a greater shot to be part of the future than our current 4th line which has added nothing this year and has been horrible on the pk.
I give Gordon credit for squeezing some blood out of a stone with not much talent, but he does not hold players accountable for their poor play. Then he breaks up the KO-Moulson-Tavares line and later laments their lack of scoring…well, play them together.
I don’t see Gordon coaching this team beyond his contract. In fact, playing Gervais this much usually results in a coach NOT making the end of the current deal.
I would keep Sutton and try and trade Witt